When The Tugger joined the Phillies, he was named to his second career All-Star game in his first season in Philadelphia. After finishing second to the Pirates in 1975, the Phillies won the National League East division title the next three seasons. They were unable to reach the World Series as they were swept by Cincinnati's "Big Red Machine" in the 1976 National League Championship Series. They lost to the Los Angeles Dodgers the following two seasons.
McGraw went to the team's general manager Paul Owens and asked not to be traded because he wanted to be there when the Phillies won it all. The Pope heeded his request and Tug paid him back in dividends.
The Phillies were battling back and forth for first place with the Montreal Expos in 1980 when the Expos came to Veterans Stadium for a crucial three game series on September 25. The Phillies won two of the three with McGraw winning the second game to pull a half game ahead of Montreal. The Phillies went to Montreal for the final series of the season with the two teams tied for first place.
The Phillies won the opening game 2–1. McGraw earned the save by striking out five of the six batters he faced. The following day McGraw entered the game in the ninth inning with the score tied at four. McGraw pitched three innings striking out three and only giving up one hit. After Mike Schmidt's eleventh inning home run put the Phillies up 6–4, McGraw pitched a 1–2–3 eleventh inning striking out Larry Parrish to end the game and clinching the National League East for the Phillies for the fourth time since joining the club.
McGraw was 5–4 with a 1.46 ERA, 75 strikeouts, and twenty saves in 1980. McGraw received consideration in balloting for both the Cy Young Award and the MVP award finishing fifth in Cy Young balloting and sixteenth for league MVP. Teammates Steve Carlton and Mike Schmidt won those awards respectively.
McGraw pitched in all five games of the 1980 National League Championship Series against the Houston Astros. The Phillies won the first game 3–1 with McGraw earning the save. The Astros won game two with an extra inning victory to send the series to Houston tied 1-1.
McGraw entered game three in the eighth inning with a runner on second, and one out. He managed to get out of the inning and keep the Astros scoreless until the eleventh inning when Joe Morgan led the inning off with a triple. Rafael Landestoy entered the game as a pinch runner for Morgan and McGraw intentionally walked the next two batters to create a force at any base. The strategy didn't work as the following batter, Denny Walling, hit a sacrifice fly to Greg Luzinski in left field scoring Landestoy.
The final two games of the series also went into extra innings. Tug earned a save in game four to even the series. McGraw blew the save in the fifth and deciding game allowing it to go into extra innings. Dick Ruthven entered the game in the ninth and pitched two perfect innings. The Phillies came back with a run in the tenth to proceed to the 1980 World Series against the Kansas City Royals.
McGraw appeared in four of the six games of the 1980 World Series striking out ten batters in 7.2 innings. The Phillies swept the first two games in Philadelphia. McGraw earned the save in game one giving the team only their second win in a World Series and the first since 1915. The Royals came back to even the series after two games in Kansas City with McGraw picking up the loss in game three.
McGraw entered game five in the seventh inning with the Phillies behind 3–2. He pitched three scoreless innings while the Phillies scored two ninth inning runs off Royals closer Dan Quisenberry to head back to Philadelphia with a 3–2 series lead. McGraw entered game six of the World Series in the eighth inning with no outs, and runners on first and second, and the Phillies up, 4–0. He allowed one inherited base runner to score but managed to get through the inning relatively unscathed. After giving up a walk and two singles to load the bases in the ninth inning, he struch out Willie Wilson, clinching the Phillies' first World Series championship.
The next day, at a victory rally at John F. Kennedy Stadium, McGraw summed it all up for the fans after 97 years of futility for the Phillies franchise saying, "All throughout baseball history, Philadelphia has had to take a back seat to New York City. Well, New York can take this championship...and stick it! 'CAUSE WE'RE NUMBER ONE!” McGraw went 2–4 with a 2.66 ERA and ten saves in the strike shortened 1981 season. The Phillies won the first half season crown but lost the 1981 National League Division Series to the Montreal Expos. In 1982, McGraw moved to a set up man role as Ron Reed and Ed Farmer earned more saves than he did that season. Prior to the start of the 1983 season, the Phillies acquired Al Holland from the San Francisco Giants to assume the closer role. McGraw battled injuries in 1983 and 1984 and following the 1984 season, McGraw retired.
On March 12, 2003, McGraw was working as an instructor for the Phillies during Spring training when he was hospitalized with a brain tumor. When surgery was performed to remove it, it revealed the tumor was malignant and inoperable. Given three weeks to live by doctors, he managed to survive nine months. He attended the closing ceremonies of Veterans Stadium where he recreated the final out of the Phillies' World Series triumph. McGraw lost his battle with cancer on January 5, 2004. The Phillies wore a Shamrock on their sleeve during the 2004 season in his honor. His son Tim McGraw recorded "Live Like You Were Dying" (written by Tim Nichols & Craig Wiseman) in his father's honor and featured the memorable clip of McGraw recording the final out of the 1980 World Series in the music video. The song reached #1 on the U.S. Billboard country music charts and held that position for a total of seven weeks. It was named as the Number One country song of 2004 by Billboard.
McGraw was cremated after his death. Nearly five years later, his son Tim McGraw took a handful of his dad's ashes and spread them on the pitcher's mound at the Phillies current home park, Citizens Bank Park, in Game 3 of the 2008 World Series. The Phillies won the game, defeating the Tampa Bay Rays 5–4, en route to the team's second World Series Championship. Tug was on the mound for both Championships!














